Conversations// The Problem With The Diversity Fight | Blogtober Day 8

Hello everyone! So before I begin this post, let me give you a disclaimer. There isn’t a single issue in calling for more diversity in books. Our world is so vastly diverse that having an all white/ all straight cast of characters is more unrealistic than even fantasy should ever be. Everyone should be able to find themselves in characters. We just need more of an effort from authors, and there is nothing wrong in asking for that.

But that isn’t the point of this post.

The point of this post is to shed some light on the way that we should not be going about asking for this change. And it’s a huge part of what makes the fight a little…annoying for me…especially in the wonderful world of Twitter.

I’ve spoken about my feelings on Twitter, both on why I am scared to write diversely as well as when it’s okay to read non-diverse books. I’m going to get into a little of the latter right now, because it’s an issue I have.

I’ve seen so many people attacking readers for the books they enjoy. I see lovers of Sarah J. Maas get some serious shit for enjoying her stories when they are far from diverse. I’ve seen a tweet that says a book is wonderful only to have a bunch  of replies condemning that reader for loving it.

Why? Because it isn’t diverse.

This can’t stand.

The problem with diversity isn’t readers enjoying stories that aren’t diverse. It’s readers enjoying stories because they aren’t diverse.

The problem isn’t that books exist that aren’t diverse. It’s books still being created that aren’t diversified.

Do you think a change will occur because you tweeted at me saying you can’t believe I love ToG. How could I do that and simultaneously support diversity? Because it’s a damn good story, that’s why. And I enjoy the world that has been created and I won’t let myself hate a book that I love.

But I will stand by you in asking Sarah J. Maas to try harder, for us, for her readers, so that we can see more diversity in those books that we love so much. I won’t offer her death threats, but I will do what I can to help these calls for diversity to be heard by all authors.

Take the issues to authors, not readers enjoying books.

Why are we fighting each other as readers and lovers of stories? I guess I wouldn’t have an issue if the tweets were kind, or just curious as to how you can like a non-diverse book while supporting diversity. But they aren’t nice. They are aggressive, and that isn’t helping a damn thing.

I will admit, I’m not one to see race, or even character descriptions, as they are described in books. I make up these images in my head and it’s not until I see fanart that I really change my mind. But I know that this is easy for me. I see myself automatically in so many characters because I am straight and white. I haven’t felt what it means to be a POC and crave that a character, a hero or heroine, looks like I do. That my ethnicity or sexual orientation is perceived as beautiful or accepted.

So for that, I want to apologize. I want to apologize if I have ever read a character that is a POC and I have perceived them as looking like me. That’s not fair. Especially when books are becoming more diverse, I don’t want to miss that diversity because I make those characters up for myself.

But if we really want to achieve this diversity across all genres and age groups, we have to stop fighting each other. We have to accept that we, as readers, can’t change the books that exist today, but we can fight for better representation in books to come.

Choose your battles and fight for diversity, not against each other.

69_Design_elements

I hope this post made sense and didn’t offend anyone. Do you see a point in fighting the readers of non-diverse books? Comments are open for discussions and opinions, but please be respectful.

 

 

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Conversations// The Problem With The Diversity Fight | Blogtober Day 8

  1. I see no point in fighting, but sometimes pointing out the lack of diversity can be useful. Maybe the author just didn’t think about it…last year I wrote a review of a dystopian future novel set in London, England later this century – and all the characters were white. It was so unreflective of London I had to comment on it. On the other hand, if a book is historical fantasy and set in a particular area (or analogue of a particular area) of the world, introducing racially diverse characters just for the sake of diversity may not ring true, but that’s where having other sorts of diversity comes in. But while I wouldn’t fight with other authors over this, I agree that far too many fantasy novels that are set in imagined worlds are de facto Northern European.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. While diversity in books is definitely something that needs addressed, I agree that some people are going about asking for diversity in books the wrong way. Since I am white, straight, middle class, and female, I have never had an issues being represented in literature. I too have felt guilt over this fact. To rectify this, I have made a conscious effort to diversity my reading. My goal is to at least read one book written by or that includes characters that are different from me. People of color, LGBT+, different religions from me, etc etc.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. That’s such a great thing to do. I’ve been working hard to become more conscious of the characters I’m reading and the backgrounds of the authors. I’ve realized I’ve read books from diverse authors but I never noticed it before because I didn’t take the time to pay attention

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s